The Messiah They Missed, the Mystery We Might Miss
Our Doctrine Through the Eyes of Paul
Paul stood in the synagogue at Thessalonica, and he did what he always did. He went in, as his manner was, and three Sabbath days he reasoned with them out of the Scriptures, opening and alleging that Christ must needs have suffered and risen again from the dead (Acts 17:1-3). He was not speaking to strangers. He was speaking to men who knew the scrolls by heart, men who stood for those readings every Sabbath, men whose whole hope was the Messiah those readings promised.
And they missed Him. Not because the evidence was absent, but because the evidence was not what they expected. Their own Scriptures had told them the Christ must suffer — and they had read past it, looking for a conqueror where the prophets had drawn a lamb. The very texts they stood for had been pointing at Jesus of Nazareth the whole time, and they could not see it.
What follows is an extract from Our Doctrine Through the Eyes of Paul — Paul in that synagogue, the argument he made, and the faces that divided when a familiar text turned in the hand.
Read it slowly.
On the first Sabbath the room was not full. By the third Sabbath it was. Word travels in a city like that.
When they gave me leave to speak — for they will give a visiting teacher leave, out of courtesy if nothing else — I opened the Scriptures.
I did not begin with what had been shown to me alone — the secret kept hidden since the world began, which no scroll in that room had ever spoken of. Those things are true, and I will die for them, but they could not be argued from the Scriptures these men knew, and a man does not lay a roof before he lays a foundation. I began where they were. I began with Moses and the Prophets, and I opened them and I alleged from them, and the argument I made was this: the Christ must needs have suffered, and risen again from the dead.
Must. That was the word that did the work and the word that cut.
I took them to the servant of Isaiah, despised and rejected, stricken, smitten of God, brought as a lamb to the slaughter, and I asked them whose servant that was. I took them to the psalm that begins with the cry of a forsaken man and ends with a suffering man’s bones out of joint and his garments parted among the watchers, and I asked them when David had ever suffered so, and of whom the Spirit spoke. I took them to the stone the builders refused, which became the head of the corner, and I asked them whether a stone could ever be raised to the head of the corner without first being refused. I did not invent a single text. It was all there. It had been there the whole time, in their own scrolls, in the very readings they stood for. The cross was not my innovation. It was their inheritance, and they had not seen it.
The faces in that room were a country I knew well. There were men who leaned forward as I opened the prophet, their lips moving with the words because they had them by heart, and then their faces changed when they understood where I was going. There is a particular stillness that comes over a man when a familiar text turns in his hand and shows him an edge he never knew it had. Some of them sat with it and let it work. Some of them closed like a shutter.
Volume Four, which contains the scene above, is still being written. But three volumes of Paul’s life and journeys are already available now, and you can find them all through my author page here on Amazon.